Click for Furuno Click for YF Listing Service Click for Northern Lights Click for Delta Click for Burger

Need Help Planning New Boat

Discussion in 'General Yachting Discussion' started by Nomad, Sep 15, 2007.

You need to be registered and signed in to view this content.
  1. Nomad

    Nomad New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2007
    Messages:
    8
    Location:
    Marina del Rey, CA
    I have a semi-custom boat under construction. Even though I don't think of it as a "yacht" and it certainly isn't in the class of many of the yachts that are the subject of this site, I am hoping that others will share their thoughts that will help me end up with a boat that ideally suits my needs and intended use.

    Fundamentally, I want a long-range fishing boat that will be comfortable enough that my family and friends will want to come along, and safe enough that I won't hesitate to take them. I think I got the basics right: Range is over 2,500 nm at 9 knots (fast trolling speed -- it will cruise at 18 knots, but I don't expect to do that much); Fishing: carries 700 gallons of bait in 5 tanks, big cockpit, searchlight sonar, flybridge and tower, lots of rod holders, etc; Comfort: stabilized, sleeps 8 in three staterooms, plus separate crew quarters (off engine room) with two berths, hi-def sat tv with flat pannels everywhere; Safety: full AIS, Sat phone, SSB, two 8-man offshore life rafts.

    What I need help with is the little stuff that I might not have thought of. For example, I became concerned that the "standard" air conditioning might not be sufficient for tropical climates, but have since confirmed that it certainly is. Another example, man overboard warning system, like Raymarine has come out with. I am going with Furuno for most stuff, but so far as I know, they don't have anything comparable.

    All comments and suggestions appreciated.

    -Rick
  2. K1W1

    K1W1 Senior Member

    Joined:
    Sep 30, 2005
    Messages:
    7,427
    Location:
    My Office
    Hi,

    Welcome to Yacht Forums

    If you can eek out 2,500 nm at 9 kts what do you estimate your range will be at the stated cruise of 18kts?
  3. Nomad

    Nomad New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2007
    Messages:
    8
    Location:
    Marina del Rey, CA

    Fuel capacity is 2300 gallons. Consumption at 18 knots (which I regard as the max cruise (based on sea trial with engines at 85-90% load), not my intended cruise) is close to 70 gal/hr. With a 10% reserve, that provides a range of 540 nm. At 8.7 knots (which is the speed at which I will spend most of my time -- perfect for trolling, and much more relaxing than any planning speed), the range should be 2,940 (again, with a 10% reserve). If I really want to "eek out" range, then I can slow down to something around 6 knots and get over 2 nmpg.

    Edit: I double checked my notes. The fuel economy at 18 knots is better than I had recalled. The range at that speed is a little better than 600 nm (also with a 10% reserve).

    Thank you for your comments.
  4. CaptPKilbride

    CaptPKilbride Senior Member

    Joined:
    Mar 16, 2004
    Messages:
    587
    Location:
    On the water
    Just remember that you need to know what is usable in that 2300 gallons. You will not be able to use all 2300 gallons. so that cuts into your "reserve" right from the get-go.
    Good tank design will help someof this, but bear in mind that the pickups will not be at the very bottom of the tanks, and based on tank design and baffles you will need to have some fuel above the level of the pickups so you will not suck air into your fuel system when the vessel rolls.
    The best feature in the fuel system in the yacht I currently run is stripping lines, these are hoses permanently plumbed to the very bottom of the tank that can be used to easily get sludge and moisture out of the bottom of the tank.
  5. AMG

    AMG YF Moderator

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2004
    Messages:
    5,380
    Location:
    Sweden
    Good advice, but the air problem can be eliminated by using a daytank I guess...?
  6. comship

    comship Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jan 27, 2007
    Messages:
    174
    Location:
    Greece
    Regarding the Air/Con here are some basics you need to consider during initial planning:

    The capacity needed to air-condition a room is expressed in Btu/h. In order to calculate the value somebody must calculate the room surface of each cabin and consider its' position in the boat. This table gives the capacity value expressed in btu/h from the surface area value for tropical conditions. When more rooms are to be conditioned, the addition of each individual capacity gives the total capacity needed for the boat.

    Heat load calculation
    This is the name of the formula which is used to find the capacity needed to air-condition a room (cabin). The most simple formula needs the following data:
    S=The floor area of the room to be conditioned.
    Te= External temperature
    Ti= Desired Inside temperature
    K=Thermal coefficient of the room to be conditioned (there must be a K, otherwise what formula is this?)
    The formula is: Heat load = S x (Te-Ti) x K.
    (Te - Ti) depends from the climate somebody has to consider: Mediterranean uses officially 8-10 which is the difference somebody wants to achieve between outside and inside temperature. For tropical climates the standard used value is 15.
    Finally we get to K:
    K value is determined by the solar gain, the quantity of people and the use of the room.
    In a very rough calculation these are the values:
    Owners cabin and guest cabins: K = 15
    Saloon or dinette without or limited window and glass area (sail yacht or power "open" configuration): K= 28-30
    Saloon or dinette with large glass area (power boat- Fly configuration): K=35
    Wheelhouse (power boat) with very large glass area: K=40

    The "K" factor utakes into account the location of the cabin with respect to the anticipated heat load. Cross reference the cabin area (in square metres) to the K-factor to determine the BTU capacity required to cool the cabin. This formula uses a differential temperature (Outside air temperature minus inside temperature) of 15 degrees which is a standard for tropical climates.
    K = 15 Owners cabin and guest cabins:
    K= 30 Saloon/dinette/galley without or limited window and glass area (sail yacht or power "open" configuration):
    K=35 Saloon or dinette with large glass area (power boat- Fly configuration):
    K=40 Wheelhouse (power boat) with very large glass area

    Apart of the above you can make modifications to the lighting to make the operation of the A/C more efficient, for example on board of our Yacht (which is currently under construction) we use only RGB LED lighting, thus the emissitive heat is extremely low and on the other hand we managed to reduce the consumption of 220V and 24V.
  7. K1W1

    K1W1 Senior Member

    Joined:
    Sep 30, 2005
    Messages:
    7,427
    Location:
    My Office
    Hi,

    You have obviously done your homework here Nomad.

    Is this a new boat or a modification of an existing one?

    I say this because you say in your first post that you have a semi custom boat under construction which to me means it's brand new being built.

    Later on you have notes which you checked to get the actual fuel consumption which is based on Sea Trial data.

    Is this info from the boat you have or a sister ship?

    If it is not your boat that was Sea Trialled did the boat that provided you the figures have the same load as the one you are having done?

    On the safety issue:

    If you are really going to go to remote locations fishing you will pretty much be on your own.

    Do you have any type of fixed fire fighting system onboard?

    AIS whilst being ok to identify you is not the same as a Satellite EPIRB, you should also make sure you rafts have SARTS in them to assist any searching aircraft.

    Another thing you should do is instigate a good fuel husbandry routine. You should use a good quality biocide to stop the growth of fungus in your fuel and if space allows I would suggest a filter setup that allows you to run with at least one in reserve like a triple Racor system where you can run on two and save the third one. If you need to change them you can keep the engine running and do them one at a time. This is especially handy if you are close to land and the sea is rough, this is a common time for fuel blockage problems as the remnants of the fuel slosh about in the tanks and wash all the mud down to the bottom and is a good time to not lose your power.

    If as I imagine with a boat like this you will be running Low Sulphur Diesel you should also consider the use of a Fuel conditioning additive that stops the reported problems that are now appearing in the marine press with the prolonged use of ultra low sulphur fuels.

    Here is an extract from *************.com, I didn't post it all as it becomes an Advert for a certain brand of fuel very quickly.

    Due to EPA regulations, many marinas are required to sell low sulfur diesel as of October 1, 2007. Even in areas where high sulfur diesel can legally be sold, only low sulfur or ultra-low sulfur diesel may be available. Although low sulfur and ultra-low sulfur diesel help to reduce harmful exhaust emissions, they can also cause damage to marine diesel engines. They destabilize much faster, have poor lubricity, contain more moisture and are more susceptible to bacteria growth than traditional high sulfur diesel fuel.

    It would also be prudent to have some advanced first aid training for yourself at least and anyone else who will be with you regularly onboard.

    I don't want to sound or read like the prophet of doom here but there is a lot to be considered when cruising outside the normal regions where help and assistance is always at hand.

    Please keep us posted as to how your adventure progresses, if as your user profile indicates are on the West Coast you are not that far from some seriously good fishing so the tales of big ones should be soon to appear :)
  8. Nomad

    Nomad New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2007
    Messages:
    8
    Location:
    Marina del Rey, CA
    I understand your point about no all of the tank(s) being usable, and until I can get some actual experience with these tanks, I won't really know how much reserve to plan. In any event, I believe that I have enough range to go anywhere I am likely to go.

    Thanks for your suggestion about the stripping lines. That is exactly the kind of thing I am looking for -- easily added during construction (not so easy afterwards) and very well worth having.
  9. Nomad

    Nomad New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2007
    Messages:
    8
    Location:
    Marina del Rey, CA
    Agreed. Thanks for your thoughts.
  10. Nomad

    Nomad New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2007
    Messages:
    8
    Location:
    Marina del Rey, CA
    Thanks for the info. I will run the calcs and see how that compares with the capacity provided. Sisterships seem to have no problems even in Panama, so I don't think this will be an issue.
  11. Nomad

    Nomad New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2007
    Messages:
    8
    Location:
    Marina del Rey, CA

    Mr. K1W1:

    Thank you for your interest and comments. To answer your questions:

    This is a new boat. The sea trial was on a sistership, which has the same power and displacement, etc. My modifications should not have a material effect, especially at displacement speeds (my tower, more of a marlin tower than a tuna tower may slow the boat down a half knot or some at planning speeds.

    Understood about the AIS (I look at that as collision avoidance) vs. EPIRB (which I expect to have two, keeping one in the dinghy. Never thought about the SARTS for the rafts -- great advice, I would have overlooked otherwise.

    Understood about the Racors. I have that setup on my current boat, and its standard on the new boat. I have added a fuel polishing system, and will have it adapted to be able to draw from the "stripping lines" recommended above.

    The advanced first-aid training is a great idea. One of my frequent guests is a trauma surgeon and another is a doctor, so at least when they are on board there is an added measure of safety. (It turns out that trauma surgeons deal with much more extreme situations than are typically handled by an emergency room surgeon.) I will also equip the boat with one of those automatic defibrilators, and will carry some oxygen.


    I do live in Marina del Rey, and so expect to use the boat on the west coast.
    Summers in the Pacific northwest (hopefully to Alaska at some point), and south down to Costa Rica and Panama.

    Thanks for your advice, please keep it coming.
  12. Innomare

    Innomare Senior Member

    Joined:
    Dec 5, 2004
    Messages:
    233
    Location:
    The Netherlands
    Rick, it seems to me you'll need two 10-man life rafts. Make sure they can float free and deploy automatically with a hydrostatic release.

    Good luck with your project,

    Bruno
  13. goplay

    goplay Senior Member

    Joined:
    Mar 16, 2006
    Messages:
    169
    Location:
    Sausalito, CA
    Sounds like an fun project. I am in the process of spec-ing out a semi-custom build as well, for the same intended crusing areas (Alaska to Panama), except there won't be as heavy emphasis on fishing.

    In addition to what you have heard, I would focus on the system details like redundancy. There are simple things, like having a redundant fresh water pump, that can make the difference between a great trip and a problematic one. I am going to the extent of having a separate battery and charger for my primary radio (bridgeable to the house batteries), this is really cheap insurance.

    Another couple of examples include: the electrical panel and electrical system layout; size of sea strainers in the engine room; water tightness of the doors and hatches; and fire fighting system as someone mentioned above.

    Lastly, given that kind of cruising, I would also have an isolation transformer and voltage booster.
  14. Nomad

    Nomad New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2007
    Messages:
    8
    Location:
    Marina del Rey, CA
    What is the unit of measure for S? Square feet seems to give a way conservative number, but square meters doesn't right either.
  15. comship

    comship Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jan 27, 2007
    Messages:
    174
    Location:
    Greece
    the unit is square meters, below is an example calculation for our Yacht which is currently building:

    Main Saloon (30.10 m2) => Heat Load= 30.10 x (10) x K(35)= 10,535 W/h x 3.4= 35,819 BTU/h

    S=The floor area of the room to be conditioned.
    Te= External temperature
    Ti= Desired Inside temperature
    K=Thermal coefficient of the room to be conditioned (there must be a K, otherwise what formula is this?)
    The formula is: Heat load = S x (Te-Ti) x K.
    (Te - Ti) depends from the climate somebody has to consider: Mediterranean uses officially 8-10 which is the difference somebody wants to achieve between outside and inside temperature. For tropical climates the standard used value is 15.
  16. Nomad

    Nomad New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2007
    Messages:
    8
    Location:
    Marina del Rey, CA
    That is good to hear. Based on my calcs, using conservative values for k (40 for the pilot house and salon, 15 for the below decks staterooms) and Te-Ti (15, although I would like to be able to produce a 20 degree differential, I find that the boat has more than 50% excess capacity (that's why I thought the unit of measure for S probably wasn't square meters).
    Anyway, thanks for the infromation!